• Contact Us
  • Events calendar
Entering Swellesley
Pinnacle, Douglas Elliman, Wellesley

The Swellesley Report

More than you really want to know about Wellesley, Mass.

  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Subscribe
  • Eat
  • Wellesley Square
  • School news
  • Private schools, sponsored by Riverbend
  • Public Schools, sponsored by Sexton
  • Camp
  • Kid stuff
  • Top 10 things to do
  • Business news
  • Embracing diversity
  • Letters to the editor
  • Guidelines for letters to the editor
  • Fire & police scanner
  • Worship
  • Live gov’t meetings
  • Events
  • About us
  • Wellesley snow plowing services
 
Needham Bank, Wellesley
Write Ahead, Wellesley

The End of the World As We Know It (Or Why I don’t think Wellesley 5th Graders Need Their Own iPads)

January 10, 2013 by admin Leave a Comment

Elizabeth Butcher, a writer and Wellesley parent, submitted the following opinion piece on the town’s plan to adopt iPads across the 5th grade in the fall.

There is a proposal under consideration to require every 5th grader in the Wellesley Public Schools to purchase an iPad as part of the 5th to 8th grade curriculum beginning this coming September.  The child would be expected to use the iPad for learning inside and outside the classroom for the next four years.  The device would be paid for by the student’s family at a cost of $155/year for a new iPad purchased through WPS, or $40/year to have an existing iPad owned by the family wiped clean and reconfigured to WPS standards.  Financial aid would be available for families demonstrating need.

One may ask why, in a town with good standardized scores, strong college placement and excellent teachers, this program is being proposed as a requirement in the fifth grade.  According to the WPS website dedicated to the 1:1 Technology Pilot Program, proponents believe that it:

  • Creates a culture where technology is used productively, responsibly, ethically, and appropriately.
  • Increases access to technology, facilitates formative assessment, supports general instruction, and enables new modes of differentiation, without stigma.
  • Prepares students to be innovators by shifting their perception of technology from toy to tool.
  • Promotes equity by addressing the “digital gap” between students without technology access at home and their peers.
  • Invests in our human capital by providing faculty with new tools and professional development to grow and develop their instructional capacity.

Of course some might argue that giving a ten-year-old full time access to an iPad is not an “appropriate” use of technology. I am not worried about porn or video games or naughty YouTube videos although that will probably happen. My concern is that our children will become mindless drones lacking in reason and human empathy.

I worry that the mental exercise of having to ponder the answer to a question or sound out a big word will be sacrificed for the sake of a quick answer.  I am concerned that if our town embraces this technology our children will be able to access definitions, pronunciations, solutions, and opinions before they have developed the skills or attention span to reason independently.

In a global economy where creativity remains one of the few sustainable advantages, our children should be learning to be collaborative learners, strong writers, attentive listeners and thoughtful problem solvers – qualities that are developed by engaging with teachers and peers, not by interfacing with a screen.

Unquestionably there is a place for technology in the upper grades of elementary school and Wellesley already does an excellent job of incorporating it appropriately in the classroom.

So, what problem or shortcomings are we are trying to fix with this 1:1 Initiative?

If we want to eliminate a digital “gap” between students, wouldn’t it be more cost effective to provide laptops or home computers to students in need?  Then, parents could decide when and what access to technology was merited at home.  And, if we are concerned about different types of learners, and research suggests iPads are a helpful tool in removing stigma, I support funding iPads for each classroom.

I would like to understand why this program should be implemented in the fifth grade, the last year of elementary school, when it has not (to my knowledge) been attempted in the high school or even the middle school.  Why not see how eighth graders do with this technology and the responsibility of owning a $500 device before mandating it for ten-year-olds?

From the populist perspective, one might ask, does a public school system have the right to require families to purchase a piece of technology for students that is part of a mandatory curriculum? The State of California does not think so.  This is not an add-on like an athletic or bussing fee.  I remember when the Spanish language program was eliminated in the Wellesley elementary schools; at that time families were not allowed to pay to have that program continue. What makes this initiative different?

Finally, in a world where so many societal and geopolitical ills are being linked to a breakdown of community and lack of human communication, do we really want to be a town that is driving our children away from collaborative learning and onto individualized screens in elementary school?

I hope not.

To learn more about the 1:1 Initiative in Wellesley please attend the forum on January 10th (today!) at 7pm in the Wakelin Room at the Wellesley Free Library.

UPDATE: Further thoughts from Elizabeth Butcher after attending the parents’ meeting.

RELATED: Wellesley planning $1M technology overhaul, iPads for all 5th graders

image_print

Filed Under: Education

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisements:

Linden Square, Wellesley
Details, Wellesley
YMCA Needham

Tip us off…

Please send tips, photos, ideas to theswellesleyreport@gmail.com

Advertisements

Wellesley Merchants
Wellesley, Jesamondo
Fay School, Southborough
Sexton test prep, Wellesley
Feldman Law
Wellesley Theatre Project
Volvo
Prepped and Polished Boston Tutoring and Test Prep
Papa Wheelies, Wellesley
Cheesy Street Grill
Admit Fit, Wellesley
charles river chamber
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Subscribe to our email newsletter

Fill out simple subscription form.

Our newsletter is free, though we appreciate any financial support for our independent journalism venture.

Follow Swellesley on Google News Showcase

The Swellesley Report has been selected to be highlighted on Google News Showcase. Please follow us there.

Most Read Posts

  • Get your Wellesley Thanksgiving dinner delivered by Feast & Fettle
  • Wellesley Police mourn passing of Officer Lamars Hughes
  • 'America Day' fails to make Wellesley High's Spirit Week cut
  • Business buzz: ChocAllure readying for Wellesley; Chamber breakfast focuses on health, housing & sports; Linden Square Starbucks is back
  • Wellesley ready to get going on equity audit

Click on Entering Natick sign to read our Natick Report

Entering Natick road sign

Upcoming Events

Nov 21
10:00 am - 11:30 am

Wellesley Health Dept. flu clinic

Nov 22
10:00 am - 3:00 pm

Blood drive in Wellesley to honor the memory of Dan McCabe

Nov 30
7:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Public forum on MBTA Communities legislation requiring multifamily zoning near train stations

Dec 2
8:30 am - 1:30 pm

Saint John School’s Trees & Trimmings Christmas Market

Dec 2
9:00 am - 5:00 pm

H.O.M.E. Store at Wellesley Village Church

View Calendar

Recent Comments

  • Frank Pinto on Wellesley Planning Board to hear update on 489 Worcester St. condo plan Monday night
  • Suz Zelenko on Wellesley business buzz: White’s Bakery, Sleek Salon signs are gone; Roof deck ‘certainly not planned to be a party place’
  • Saralea Strock on Wellesley Police mourn passing of Officer Lamars Hughes
  • Angela Eleazar on ‘Torn’ Wellesley Advisory Committee not sold on zoning article for Sisters of Charity property
  • Dan on ‘America Day’ fails to make Wellesley High’s Spirit Week cut

Links we like

  • Danny's Place
  • Great Runs
  • Jack Sanford: Wellesley's Major League Baseball Star
  • Tech-Tamer
  • The Wellesley Wine Press
  • Universal Hub
  • Wellesley Sports Discussion Facebook Group

© 2023 The Swellesley Report
Site by Tech-Tamer · Login