• Contact Us
  • Events calendar
Entering Swellesley
Pinnacle, Wellesley

The Swellesley Report

More than you really want to know about Wellesley, Mass.

  • Advertise
  • Contribute
  • Eat
  • Wellesley Square
  • School
  • Top 10 things to do
  • Embracing diversity
  • Charities/Community
  • Arts
  • Camp
  • Kids
  • Environment/Sustainability
  • Events
  • About us
  • Subscribe
  • Natick Report
  • COVID-19
  • Letters to the Editor
  • 2021 Town Election
  • Bulletin Board
Needham Bank, Wellesley
Boston Sports Institute, Wellesley

Letter to the editor: concerns about denouncing Columbus

February 25, 2021 by admin 11 Comments

I am concerned about articles that denounce Columbus and wish to replace Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples Day. I have no problem with the latter but it should be a different day, preferably a day chosen by them. Most people know little about Columbus and are blaming him for things he did not do.

I spent several years doing research for my acclaimed book, Columbus and the Quest for Jerusalem. He sailed west toward what he assumed would be China. There he expected to set up a trading post the profits from which were to be used to take Jerusalem back from the Muslims. This is in his writings and in the agreements with Queen Isabella. When he arrived in Hispaniola he became friends with the natives, especially the chief Guacanagari,  saying they were the best people in the world.

The Santa Maria went aground on that voyage so he had to return to get a rescue ship. He had to leave 39 men behind and left strict instructions that they treat the natives well and not go raping and marauding. He took 6 back with him—all were baptized. Baptized people could not be enslaved.  Two decided to remain at court, one became his adopted godson, the others wanted to go back home. When they arrived back, all of the men he had left were dead. The chief told Columbus that the men had gone against his orders and went to another village where they did the dastardly deeds. The people from that village came and killed them. The men  who just came with Columbus wanted to kill the natives in return but Columbus said absolutely not. He continually asked the Queen to send priests to baptize the natives so they would be saved. Please retain Columbus Day and suggest that people learn more about him. Make Indigenous Peoples Day a different day. Thank you.

Carol L. Delaney
Providence, RI

print

Share

Filed Under: Letters to the Editor

Comments

  1. Carol Delaney says

    February 28, 2021 at 6:37 am

    To the person who asked about the 6 natives he took back on the first voyage… 2 decided to remain at court, one became his adopted godson, the other 3 wanted to go back home but one died at sea. Please read my book for all the references in the bibliography.

    Reply
  2. Daniel says

    February 26, 2021 at 7:31 pm

    Dear Professor Delaney,

    Thank you for your perspective. I think some sources to support your claims would be helpful. I am wondering what Columbus did with the 6 baptized Indians who were not enslaved that he took with him back to Spain. Please also address Columbus’ subsequent voyages, during which reports of rape, enslavement, and forced labor of the indigenous population are abundant.

    Reply
    • Donna Ticchi says

      February 28, 2021 at 12:11 am

      Hi Daniel – I have e-mailed Professor Delaney and shared the link to this page so that she can respond to you directly. In the meantime, many of your questions can be answered by viewing Delaney’s Presidential Lecture at Roger Williams University (2017). This is the link to the Unite Wellesley website, where the video appears. You have to scroll down a bit. https://www.italiansarepeopletoo.com
      Also check out Delaney’s letter to the Wellesley Select Board (2020):
      https://www.italiansarepeopletoo.com/post/professor-carol-delaney

      Reply
    • Carol Delaney says

      February 28, 2021 at 6:38 am

      REad my book and you will find what you want

      Reply
    • Carol Delaney says

      February 28, 2021 at 8:41 am

      I think I already replied?? All the references are in my book, take a look. carol
      Also wrote you I think: 2 natives wanted to stay at court, one became CC’s godson, the others wanted to go home but one died at sea. And it was the horrible men sent over by Isabella after the first voyage, with 17 ships!! and it was Ovando and Bobadilla who did the horrible deeds against CCs orders… CC was one man among several hundred and unable to stop them. carol

      Reply
    • Donna Ticchi says

      February 28, 2021 at 10:01 am

      Daniel – Please also read point #3 in this link: https://91a4ccf7-fee2-4600-9bad-1fc70c578ce5.filesusr.com/ugd/0f16c3_b430c56fe4be44e5ae7074548a527dbe.pdf This information was reviewed and approved by Professor Delaney before it was posted on the Unite Wellesley site.

      Reply
  3. M. Miwakawa says

    February 26, 2021 at 3:49 am

    Ideed, I did not know that. Not from current arguments and not from the brief coverage he got in my high scool history classes.

    Reply
  4. Donna Ticchi says

    February 25, 2021 at 7:47 pm

    Thank you so much for your timely and informative letter, Carol.
    If readers would like to learn more about Professor Delaney’s work, please check out the United Wellesley website at http://www.UniteWellesley.com. There you will find a video of Professor Delaney delivering the Presidential Lecture at Rogers Williams University as well as her March 2020 letter to the Select Board: https://www.italiansarepeopletoo.com/post/professor-carol-delaney

    Reply
  5. Denise Wood says

    February 25, 2021 at 11:41 am

    Carol, I found your article extremely interesting. The position you stated for maintaining Columbus Day was very well explained. I agree that the Indigenous People’s Day should be observed, but definitely on a separate day focusing on their unique customs and history.

    Reply
    • Mary Bowers says

      February 25, 2021 at 8:30 pm

      I agree….very strong article!

      Reply
  6. Marie Brown says

    February 25, 2021 at 11:07 am

    So important that everyone in Wellesley can read this post. Do you have any influence to get it published in this week’s “.Townsman”?

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Linden Square, Wellesley
Fran's Flowers
Clearhaven Recovery

Tip us off…

Please send tips, photos, ideas to [email protected]
Wellesley Square ad
Wellesley, Jesamondo
Admit Fit, Wellesley
Sexton test prep
Feldman Law
Fay School, Southborough
Wellesley Theatre Project
The Moving-Pictures Company
image of Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19)
covid vaccine
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
Never miss a post with our free daily Swellesley Report email
Name: 
Your email address:*
Please wait...
Please enter all required fields Click to hide
Correct invalid entries Click to hide

You can subscribe for free, though we appreciate any contribution that supports our independent journalism.

Click here to read our Natick Report

Natick Report

Most Read Posts

  • Newton-Wellesley Orthopedic Walk-In—no appointment needed
  • Wellesley summer camp listings 2021 — find the experience of a lifetime
  • Wellesley Business Buzz: Poppin In at Linden Square; Chase Bank site becomes sign central; Women-owned businesses; Forklift enters Wellesley meal-delivery scene
  • Wellesley's Lee Delaney, CEO of BJ's Wholesale, passes away at age 49
  • WHS senior scavenger hunt to blanket Wellesley

Events Calendar

« April 2021 » loading...
S M T W T F S
28
29
30
31
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
1
Thu 22

Ben Franklin, The Early Years: Wellesley Historical Society online lecture

April 22 @ 7:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Mon 26

Virtual lab tour, pooled COVID testing

April 26 @ 6:30 pm - 7:30 pm
Wed 28

Fay School virtual information session

April 28 @ 10:00 am - 11:00 am

Pages

  • Guidelines for Letters to the Editor
  • How to submit your flyer for the Community Bulletin Board page
  • Wellesley Community Bulletin Board
  • Wellesley coronavirus (COVID-19) updates
  • Wellesley’s 7 official scenic roads
  • Wellesley, Mass., fishing spots
  • Wellesley Choral Society
  • Wellesley College Notable Alumnae
  • Wellesley College, Wellesley, Mass.
  • Wellesley outdoor art gallery
  • Wellesley restaurants offering take-out and delivery
  • Wellesley, Massachusetts restaurant — Amarin of Thailand

Recent Comments

  • Maria T on Wellesley Give & Take update
  • Haihong Li on Wellesley Give & Take update
  • bob McGrath on Wellesley Police log: Sneaking into stables; pricey check scheme; neighbor throwdown
  • Erica Johnson on Wellesley Police log: Sneaking into stables; pricey check scheme; neighbor throwdown
  • Jean Ann Schulte on Babson to the rescue: Survey seeks to get to bottom of Wellesley Square issues

Links we like

  • Great Runs
  • Jack Sanford: Wellesley's Major League Baseball Star
  • Taquitos.net
  • Tech-Tamer
  • The Wellesley Wine Press
  • Universal Hub
  • Wellesley Sports Discussion Facebook Group

Categories

  • 2021 Town Election (21)
  • Animals (387)
  • Antiques (48)
  • Art (544)
  • Beyond Wellesley (31)
  • Books (345)
  • Business (1,382)
  • Camp (2)
  • Careers/jobs (46)
  • Churches (73)
  • Clubs (211)
  • Construction (282)
  • Dump (114)
  • Education (2,919)
    • Babson College (244)
    • Bates Elementary School (14)
    • Dana Hall School (29)
    • Fiske Elementary School (6)
    • Hardy Elementary School (33)
    • Hunnewell Elementary School (34)
    • MassBay (49)
    • Schofield Elementary School (20)
    • Sprague Elementary School (19)
    • St. John School (1)
    • Tenacre Country Day School (9)
    • Upham Elementary School (30)
    • Wellesley College (600)
    • Wellesley High School (895)
    • Wellesley Middle School (195)
  • Embracing diversity (52)
  • Entertainment (728)
  • Environment (680)
  • Fashion (134)
  • Finance (13)
  • Fire (144)
  • Food (328)
  • Fundraising (565)
  • Gardens (137)
  • Government (425)
    • 2020 Town Election (47)
  • Health (760)
    • COVID-19 (152)
  • History (360)
  • Holidays (367)
  • Houses (121)
  • Humor (45)
  • Kids (820)
  • Law (3)
  • Letters to the Editor (12)
  • Media (63)
  • METCO (4)
  • Military (3)
  • Morses Pond (97)
  • Music (545)
  • Natick Report (28)
  • Neighbors (252)
  • Obituaries (62)
  • Outdoors (589)
  • Parenting (60)
  • Police (703)
    • Crime (357)
  • Politics (545)
  • Real estate (294)
  • Religion (127)
  • Restaurants (306)
  • Safety (143)
  • Scouts (1)
  • Senior citizens (111)
  • Shopping (123)
  • Sports (906)
  • STEM (107)
  • Technology (158)
  • Theatre (383)
  • Town Meeting (22)
  • Transportation (212)
  • Travel (12)
  • Uncategorized (1,212)
  • Volunteering (319)
  • Weather (169)
  • Wellesley Election 2019 (21)
  • Wellesley Free Library (259)
  • Wellesley's Wonderful Weekend (5)
RSS Feed Icon Subscribe to RSS Feed

© 2021 The Swellesley Report
Site by Tech-Tamer · Login