The call to take up words and defend the very bedrock of journalism came from no less an institution than The Boston Globe. Marjorie Pritchard, a deputy managing editor of the 146-year-old daily publication was fed up with the press as a whole being called an “Enemy of the People.” Taking a fight-back stance, she reached out to editorial boards nationwide asking them to join in a kind of write-in. The idea is that newsrooms would collectively publish editorials on August 16 denouncing what the newspaper called a “dirty war against the free press.”
What Pritchard has done here is ask for back-up as she leads an effort to push back against a bully. You know who that bully is, right?
In case you’ve been in parts unknown, unplugged, surrounded by family and friends, blissfully unaware of Tweets and tirades, here’s a brief. Earlier this month President Donald Trump said via Twitter that the press was the Enemy of the People. Again. Apparently, he noted with glee, the Fake News hates it, just hates it, when he trots out that Enemy of the People label. According to the president, Fake News journalists and their pesky fact-checking toadies at the copy desk “cause great division & distrust.” They’re responsible for war, too, the dangerous sick-os.
So which news outlets, exactly, are Fake News operations? Well, just like there are no always-good children, every news agency is at least sometimes naughty by the standards of the president. Therefore every news agency of note ends up in the president’s Fake News time-out corner eventually.
OK, maybe not The Swellesley Report. Because we’re so very local, the news we cover is about as real as it gets. We’re fly-under-the radar types who post about school events and other around-town doings. Hard-hitting journalism for us: “Will Wellesley College ban dogs on Lake Waban path?” A close second: “Local reporter (me) almost hit by car in Wellesley.” Yes, that’s almost.
As you already know, nothing much happens in Wellesley. That’s why you moved here and love it. That’s why you read Swellesley, to have this knowledge confirmed and to bear witness to our daily documentation of, well, the dailiness of a quiet community.
What’s important about this isn’t so much what we do, it’s that we can do it. Bob and I learned all about the sacred principles of a free and independent press at Boston University. He was a journalism major, I went for the major the less-focused types embraced, “Communications.” We learned all about the holiness of our calling and how freedom of the press was enshrined in the Constitution. When you get to the very end of that august document, keep reading. We journalist types are the ones covered by the First Amendment, the one that says, “Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…”
Heady stuff, to be backed up by historical documents and Congress itself.
Indeed, because of this back-up no one tries to stop us from publishing the weekly police log, or about car crashes, or the occasional tragedy that of course touches even our quiet corner of the world. We are a free and independent press, and it hardly gets more free and independent that what Bob and I do every day.
In fact, we started out doing it about 13 years ago literally for free, just a public service from two people curious about what blogging was all about, posts sent out over the internet to whoever might be reading. We started out by putting up a list of Wellesley’s sledding hills. Then we wrote about businesses opening and closing. School plays, Little League sign-ups, pictures of the noteworthy or unusual — no story was too small then, nor is it now. Post by post we got more and more readers.
What started out as the “Hey kids, let’s put on a show” model of journalism eventually turned into A Thing, if I can be so immodest. Best of all, there was nobody around to stop us. We didn’t have to appear before the Wellesley Board of Selectmen for approval. We didn’t have to wring our hands and hope that Wellesley’s 240 Town Meeting members would vote yes on a proposal sanctioning our right to exist, just as long as we followed a few simple rules. We just started pecking away at our keyboards and sending our reports on the front-lines of Wellesley out into the world. We appreciate that thousands of you subscribe to Swellesley and follow us across our social media accounts.
Now we find our colleagues, especially those who report nationally and internationally, toiling in an Orwellian-type workplace, where their right to write is under attack, and the analogies get weird. In this world, journalists are Enemy of the People. Fact-checking is fake. Constitutional shrines are false idols. Go right ahead and tread on me, the Fourth Estate, right into the ground if you can get away with it.
To get all this to work, all you need do as an informed public is sit back, relax, open your hearts and minds and welcome the rise of the Fifth Estate: Propaganda. It’s a new branch of government that isn’t really a branch at all, it’s more something grafted onto a mighty trunk. That mighty trunk is Government Control.
Here’s how it works: start with a long-standing tree. Envision its branches, reaching out. Because those branches are healthy and strong, the massive tree stands tall and powerful. Now chop off the Legislative Branch of the tree. Next, chop off the Judicial Branch of the tree. Finally, the Fourth Estate goes, a Fake Branch if ever there was one, until finally we’re left with one thing standing — an Executive Trunk.
Careful, there. It’s a massive trunk, it comes with a lot of baggage, and it thinks it can stand alone. That form of government can’t be good for any of us.
Thanks to the New York Times (A Free Press Needs You) and Boston Globe (Journalists are not the enemy) for giving us some love in their editorials.
HOW TO SUPPORT SWELLESLEY:
Bravo Swellesley Report. I don’t mind editor’s personal opinions, whether they are about a local eatery or a political matter. It is up to me to decide how I deal with the opinion. I am proud to have our town’s one-couple’s Swellesley effort be listed in the New York Times among papers from all over the country.
Proud to see The Swellesley Report holding up its end for a free press unbent by the whims of any official, town or federal.
Well-deserved recognition! Thank you for your consistently fair and honest reporting. Keep writing – our community needs your voice.
I think you’re making too heavy an assumption that every Wellesley resident is a Trump hater. You’re allowed to say whatever you want in your publication, can’t take that away from anyone, and making the NYT is admirable and something to be congratulated on. But I don’t subscribe to Swellesley Report for your political opinions. The tree analogy? Spare me. 😂😂😂. I have enjoyed your local stories and updates, keeping it simple. Bye now, Swellesley Report. Time to unsubscribe.
Thanks for writing. We recognize that Wellesley has its share of Trump supporters, though our hope is that regardless of political leanings that our readers support a free press.
I definitely support a free press, and everyone should!I just liked you better when you stuck to investigating the goings-on in town, always right on the things we wondered about, providing photos of crazy stuff around town. Once you felt it was a good idea to make your political views known (I don’t recall any politicizing prior to 2016 or I’m sure I’d have unsubscribed then–isn’t that telling?), the Swellesley Report became just another media outlet that I don’t want to watch or read.
Interesting … that someone who would value local news would stop reading a publication because that publication does not agree with everything they believe. I read the Wall St Journal even though I may not agree with everything on their editorial page. We need to listen to alternative voices or we all lose the value of being challenged and learning from others.
You’re missing the point. I’m not unsubscribing because I’m a Trump supporter. I’m unsubscribing because what I have always enjoyed about Swellesley Report is its great coverage of all things Wellesley, not the authors’ beliefs. It was a nice departure from all of the crazy stuff going on in the world. Go back to telling us which businesses are closing and which new ones are coming in!
Well, I think everyone recognizes that there is a diversity of political opinion in town and is happy about that. But unfortunately, this administration has made the issue of a free press, something all political stripes should and previously did value, into a partisan issue. So while local papers like this one continue reporting on the local news we all value, they are suddenly swept up in the category of “enemy of the people.” And it is important for all people of all opinions that the press, local or international, remain free from and push back against such misjudged and cynical slurs. So, thanks Swellesley Report for doing a great job.
A free press truly is essential to our democracy. I’m grateful for your dedication and appreciate your hyper-local focus. Thank you for caring about our community and for sharing information that helps us better understand our town. It was wonderful to see you recognized in The Times this morning–my mom called at 7 a.m. from New Jersey to be sure I saw it!
Thank you for the editorial regarding the Freedom of the Press, Mel Miller
Congratulations on your recognition by the NYT.
Well done, you! And thanks for keeping me informed about all things local to our town. Please keep up the good reporting.
Bravo, Swellesley Report. You do Wellesley proud. Thank you for calling things the way they are. (And thanks for the tree analogy!)
How great to wake up to “The Swellesley Report” on page A20 of the printed (old school) “New York Times.” In response to “The Boston Globe’s” call to action to news outlets across the country to join together today to address President Trump’s frequent attacks on the news media, the “NY Times” included a portion of the Brown’s thoughtful article. Congratulations!
The Swellesley Report is the epitome of local reporting, and your community of readers is proud of you! Being recognized as a publication of value in the New York Times editorial page is a great honor and recognition of your hard work. Congratulations!